Resource

Peer Graded Assessments

Author: ATU Galway

What is it?

Students grade and/or provide feedback on each other’s assignments using rubrics/grading criteria they have developed themselves or with which they have been provided. This helps students to identify mistakes in their peer’s work and help each other learn from their mistakes.

Advantages & Challenges

Advantages

Challenges

Advantages

Challenges

Tips for Use

Consider providing students with training on how to grade assessments and give constructive feedback.
Provide students with a clear and easy to follow grading rubric to follow when looking at their peer’s assessments.
Consider using anonymous peer assessment to minimize bias and encourage honest feedback. This can help students feel more comfortable providing constructive feedback.
Monitor the peer assessment process closely to ensure fairness and consistency. Review assessments for accuracy and provide feedback to students on their evaluations to improve their assessment skills.

Resources

Maynooth University:Self and Peer Assessment | Maynooth University
Deakin university: Communication skills (deakin.edu.au)
McGill University: Peer Assessment Resource Document (mcgill.ca)
Leeds Institute for Teaching Excellence: Microsoft Word – Pugh|CompendiumOfAssessment.docx (leeds.ac.uk)(page 66)
University of Galway: https://www.universityofgalway.ie/media/celt/files/curriculardesignandinnovation/SelfPeerAssess_QG_v1.3-(1).pdf (Curricular Design & Innovation – University of Galway)
Royal Society of Chemistry: Self and peer assessment | Principles of assessment for learning | Resource | RSC Education

Sample Rubrics

Trinity Western University: Rubrics & Peer Assessment | May 2020 (twu.ca)
Deakin University: Communication skills (deakin.edu.au)

Related Tools

Recent Additions

Assessment

Paper

An Exploration of Student and Staff Experiences of Assessment, Feedback, and Academic Integrity across three programmes in a Technological University

E-Book

101 Creative Ideas to use AI in education

Nerantzi, C., Abegglen, S., Karatsiori, M. and Martínez-Arboleda, A. (Eds.)

Whitepaper

Unlocking the Power of Generative AI Models and Systems such as GPT-4 and ChatGPT for Higher Education: A Guide for Students and Lecturers

Gimpel et al

Report

Student Percpections of genarative AI

Sue Attewell (JISC)

E-Book

Using Generative AI Effectively in Higher Education Sustainable and Ethical Practices for Learning, Teaching and Assessment

Edited By Sue Beckingham, Jenny Lawerence, Stephen Powell, Peter Hartley

Paper

The AI Assessment Scale (AIAS) in action: A pilot implementation of GenAI-supported assessment

Leon Furze, Mike Perkins, Jasper Roe & Jason MacVaugh